Argumentative Comparison or contrast outline Assignment: A good boss and a bad boss

BLOCK OUTLINE

I. INTRODUCTION

Hook: 

Background information about the two subjects: 

Thesis statement: 

II. The First Subject 

    A.  State the first point or aspect of comparison/contrast 

             1. Minor supporting detail

             2. Minor supporting detail

    B. State the second point or aspect of comparison/contrast 

             1. Minor supporting detail

             2. Minor supporting detail

   C. State the third point or aspect of comparison/contrast 

             1. Minor supporting detail

             2. Minor supporting detail

*Don’t mention the second subject in your first body paragraph. Use the same aspects/points in both paragraphs.

III. The Second Subject

    A. State the first point of comparison/contrast of the second subject 

            1. Minor supporting detail

            2. Minor supporting detail

   B. State the second point of comparison/contrast of the second subject 

             1. Minor supporting detail

             2. Minor supporting detail

   C. State the third point of comparison/contrast of the second subject 

             1. Minor supporting detail

             2. Minor supporting detail

 IV. Conclusion

Restate thesis in a creative way

Make a summary of the main points

Insert a remarkable thought or end with a wrap-up statement

POINT-BY-POINT OUTLINE

I. INTRODUCTION

Hook: 

Background information about the two subjects: 

Thesis statement: 

II. The First Point 

    A. Subject A: 

             1. Minor supporting detail

             2. Minor supporting detail

    B. Subject B: 

             1. Minor supporting detail

             2. Minor supporting detail

III. The Second Point 

    A. Subject A: 

            1. Minor supporting detail

            2. Minor supporting detail

    B. Subject B: 

             1. Minor supporting detail

             2  Minor supporting detail

IV. The Third Point 

    A. Subject A: 

            1. Minor supporting detail

            2. Minor supporting detail

    B. Subject B: 

             1. Minor supporting detail

             2  Minor supporting detail

 V. Conclusion

Restate thesis in a creative way

Make a summary of the main points

Insert a remarkable thought or end with a wrap-up statement

EXAMPLE OF BLOCK METHOD

Title: Comparative Analysis of Cats and Dogs as Ideal Pets

I. Introduction

1. Opening Statement: The debate surrounding “cats and dogs” has persisted for generations.
2. Introduction to General Topic: It’s rare to find someone who equally adores both creatures.
3. Introduction of Specific Subjects: Cats’ revered status in ancient Egypt because of their sweetness, companionship, and independence contrasts with dogs’ evolution as loyal, playful, and intelligent companions.
4. Thesis Statement: Choosing between cats and dogs as pets involves assessing their management, costs, and behavior, but after close examination it becomes apparent that cats are better suited for individuals with constrained schedules and a preference for minimal disturbances.

II. Body (Subject A: Cats)

1. Cats and Lifestyle Impact: Cats’ independence means they are less disruptive to owners’ routines.
   • They follow instincts rather than commands.
   • Cats require minimal supervision during the day and use a sandbox for toileting.
2. Vet Visits and Cat Management:
   • Cats can be easily managed in cages during vet visits.
   • Their calm demeanor reduces noise and simplifies transportation.
3. Travel Considerations for Cat Owners:
   • Cats can tolerate short periods alone without distress.
   • Provision of litter boxes and food during travel.
4. Economical Aspects of Cat Ownership:
   • Lower costs for cat food (approx. $500/year).
   • Less frequent vet visits due to indoor lifestyle.
   • Limited grooming expenses as cats are self-maintaining.
5. Potential Drawbacks of Cats:
   • Cat urine odor challenges for carpet cleaning.
   • Scratching behavior can damage furniture.

III. Body (Subject B: Dogs)

1. Dogs and Lifestyle Impact:
   • Dogs’ reliance on companionship and outdoor activity.
   • Regular interaction required; not suited for extended periods alone.
   • Walking demands, especially for working owners.
2. Vet Visits and Dog Management:
   • Larger dogs pose challenges in cages at vet clinics.
   • Active and potentially noisy within clinic settings.
3. Travel Considerations for Dog Owners:
   • Dogs experience separation anxiety when left alone.
   • Need for pet care arrangements during travel.
4. Economic Implications of Dog Ownership:
   • Higher dog food costs (approx. $2700/year).
   • Frequent vet visits due to outdoor exposure.
   • Increased grooming expenses for bathing, nail trimming, etc.
5. Potential Drawbacks of Dogs:
   • Potential for carpet accidents, but less intense odor than cat urine.
   • Puppies can damage furniture through chewing behaviors.

IV. Conclusion

1. Concluding Statement: Selecting a pet involves evaluating lifestyle, finances, and behavior, but after a close analysis cats suit those with limited time and who desire less disruption.
2. Highlighting Attributes:  While dogs boast qualities of loyalty, playfulness, and intelligence, cats exude independence, sweetness, and offer unwavering companionship with significantly fewer disruptions, management requirements, and financial burdens.
3. Closing Remark: Irrespective of the chosen furry companion, the foremost endeavor remains fostering an environment of warmth and care within a home, ensuring the mutual growth of both pet and owner.