suggested essay title and outline focusing on the middle to the end part of the attached document, with an emphasis on the comparative analysis of the political styles of Carrie Lam and John Lee, especially highlighting how John Lee can leverage new opportunities and past experiences to drive improvements.
Essay Title:
Navigating Policy Windows: A Comparative Analysis of Carrie Lam and John Lee’s Political Strategies in the Lantau Tomorrow Vision
Essay Outline
Introduction (Approx. 200 words)
- Purpose of the Essay: Introduce the aim of the essay, which is to compare the political styles of Carrie Lam and John Lee, focusing on their approaches to the Lantau Tomorrow Vision and implications for future governance.
- Context: Briefly describe the Lantau Tomorrow Vision, including its objectives and the controversy it has sparked regarding land reclamation and development.
- Thesis Statement: Propose that John Lee, armed with the lessons from Carrie Lam’s tenure and a new policy window, has a unique opportunity to refine the project’s direction and enhance governmental legitimacy.
Background of Lantau Tomorrow Vision (Approx. 200 words)
- Overview: Recap the initiation and development phases of the Lantau Tomorrow Vision under Carrie Lam.
- Carrie Lam’s Political Style: Analyze Carrie Lam’s approach to policy-making, focusing on her leadership during the critical phases of the Lantau Tomorrow Vision.
Transition to John Lee’s Leadership (Approx. 300 words)
- End of Carrie’s Tenure: Discuss the end of Carrie Lam’s tenure, noting the public and political climate she left behind.
- Introduction of John Lee: Introduce John Lee as the new Chief Executive, noting the shift in leadership style and potential policy windows that have opened.
- Comparison of Political Styles: Contrast Carrie Lam’s assertive, top-down approach with John Lee’s potentially more consultative and pragmatic style.
Analysis of John Lee’s Approach to Lantau Tomorrow Vision (Approx. 600 words)
- Initial Moves by John Lee: Describe John Lee’s initial actions or public statements regarding the Lantau Tomorrow Vision, if available.
- Learning from Past Mistakes: Analyze how John Lee can use the shortcomings and successes of Carrie Lam’s approach to better navigate public opposition and environmental concerns.
- Strategic Refocusing: Discuss how John Lee can strategically refocus aspects of the Lantau Tomorrow Vision, particularly through the lens of improving public engagement and transparency to restore trust.
Potential for Policy Innovation under John Lee (Approx. 400 words)
- Policy Window Opportunities: Explore the concept of “policy windows” as described by John Kingdon, suggesting how John Lee might use current opportunities to push forward new policy initiatives or revisions to the Lantau Tomorrow Vision.
- Incorporating Previous Experience: Evaluate how John Lee’s previous governmental roles could inform his approach to managing large-scale infrastructure projects, emphasizing a balanced approach to economic development and environmental sustainability.
Recommendations for John Lee (Approx. 200 words)
- Enhanced Engagement Strategies: Recommend strategies for better public and stakeholder engagement that could be implemented under John Lee’s tenure.
- Policy Adjustments: Suggest specific policy adjustments or shifts that could align the Lantau Tomorrow Vision more closely with current public needs and environmental standards.
Conclusion (Approx. 100 words)
- Recap of Key Points: Summarize the main arguments made in the essay, reinforcing the idea that John Lee has the opportunity to redefine the trajectory of the Lantau Tomorrow Vision.
- Final Thoughts: Conclude with reflections on the potential long-term impacts of John Lee’s leadership style on Hong Kong’s political landscape and infrastructural development.
References
- Citation of Sources: Include a list of all sources cited throughout the essay in APA format.
This outline provides a structured approach to critically analyzing the transition in leadership styles between Carrie Lam and John Lee, with a focus on how this transition affects the ongoing Lantau Tomorrow Vision project. The essay will explore how John Lee can leverage new policy windows to enhance project outcomes and government legitimacy.
Comment are made by the teacher, that the focus of the report should be on the comparison of lam and lee apprach but not not critised on lam’s policy making process, so the front to middle part of the ppt is not soing well, but the middle-end part is more important and ask for more elabrate.