A power generation company is planning to upgrade its existing power plant to meet growing demand and improve operational efficiency. The engineering team is tasked with evaluating different electrical machines to determine the most suitable option for the upgrade. The team must conduct a thorough analysis of the available literature to assess the validity and accuracy of each machine’s performance characteristics.
Objectives:
-
Review literature to gather information on the performance characteristics of synchronous generators, induction generators, and DFIGs.
-
Analyze the validity and accuracy of the performance data presented in the literature for each type of electrical machine.
-
Compare the efficiency, reliability, and suitability of synchronous generators, induction generators, and DFIGs for power generation applications.
-
Make recommendations based on the findings to guide the selection of the most appropriate electrical machine for the power plant upgrade.
Case
Rubrics:
|
Criteria |
Rated Marks |
Achieved Marks |
|
Demonstration of In-depth Engineering Knowledge |
8 |
|
|
– Thorough understanding of electrical machine performance characteristics |
|
|
|
– Comprehensive analysis of literature review findings |
|
|
|
– Application of advanced analytical techniques |
|
|
|
Consideration of Wide-ranging or Conflicting Technical, Engineering, and Other Issues |
6 |
|
|
– Identification and analysis of diverse technical and engineering issues related to electrical machine performance |
|
|
|
– Addressing conflicting viewpoints or findings in the literature review |
|
|
|
– Incorporation of relevant non-technical factors (e.g., economic, environmental) impacting machine selection |
|
|
|
Integration of Diverse Stakeholder Needs |
4 |
|
|
– Recognition of various stakeholders involved in power generation projects (e.g., engineers, management, regulatory bodies) |
|
|
|
– Consideration of differing needs and priorities among stakeholders |
|
|
|
– Incorporation of stakeholder feedback or perspectives in the analysis and recommendations |
|
|
|
Clarity, Organization, and Presentation |
2 |
|
|
– Clear and concise presentation of case study objectives, methodology, and findings |
|
|
|
– Logical organization of content with well-defined sections and sub-sections |
|
|
|
– Effective use of language and visuals to convey information |
|
|
|
Total |
20 |
|