Discuss Experience, Interpretation and Evaluate a poem/song. Discuss literary elements and devices used.

Ready to write Essay #1?

Essay #1 is designed to help you demonstrate the tools you worked with in Module 2 on poetry and song.  

If you are turning in your essay and the submission portal is closed, contact me through the InBox. I’ll open the Module for Late Submissions 

Learning Objectives

In completing this essay, you should 

  • be able to approach any text by  interpreting and evaluating a work of literature 
  • be able to recognize and discuss the basic elements or devices in a poem or song as a reader-response.
  • be able to structure and organize an essay based on making inferences to argue your point.

Instructions

  • Choose one of the assigned prompts listed below.
  • Choose one of the Casebook assigned poems or songs to explore and interpret through a  Reader-Response Lens.

What Should You Submit? Three Items.

  • Your completed essay  
  • A rationale for choosing the prompt and poem/song (name the prompt) and what you learned about the poet, songwriter, or singer.
  • An explanation of what you learned about writing on the differences between experiencing, interpreting, and evaluating

See the chart below for a full description of essay requirements.

  • (Test your ideas under brainstorming. Get clarification. Ask for feedback! You can always return to Brainstorming at any time to test or exchange ideas.)

What Prompts Can You Choose From?

Prompt 1 

  • In interacting with the poem or song, how did you find meaning in the poem through applying all three methods–experiencing, interpreting, and evaluating You do not have to discuss the approaches to the same degree, but you must mention all three in your essay.  For example, if you approached your analysis more through experience to give the poem meaning, include a paragraph on why the other two approaches did not work so well for you.

Prompt 2

  • You explored the elements and devices in the poem. In analyzing the elements and devices, how did your own experiences and observations about the subject matter or themes in the poem influence how you gave the elements and devices meaning?  Focus on you as much as on the poem.

 Prompt 3

If you want to do a variation of a prompt, post your inquiry under brainstorming or send me a private message through the Inbox with a rationale of how you want to alter the prompt and why.

How Will You Be Graded?

See the Rubric at the end of this page.

The following chart gives the details of the requirements, helpful hints, samples, reminders, and optional links.

Requirements, Reminders, Samples & Links for Essay #1
 Requirements Reminders  MLA links, Devices and Optional Samples
  • Write a Reader-Response essay on one of the assigned Casebook works.
  • Length:1000 words. 
  • Title essay to hint at central idea.
  • Paste the poem or song after the title and number the lines, so you can refer to the lines
  • Include 5 short quotes (one word to a short stanza) in the body paragraphs. 
  • Name two or more poetry devices (repetition, metaphor, etc.) in your discussion. These can be stated in your thesis or in the body of the essay.
  • All three approaches do not have to appear in each topic sentence or paragraph.
  • include Additional materials with your submission.
  • Shorter quotes of poetry three lines or less are integrated into the flow of the general writing.
  • Quotes that take up more than 4 lines in your essay are indented 10 spaces. Unless used in the quote itself, leave out quotation marks.
  • Double-space the entire essay.
  • Do not use a quote in the essay’s introduction or in topic sentence.
  • A central idea gives the essay its focus; the thesis gives the essay its structure.
    • See the samples on how to formulate these connections. 
  • To experience means to focus on which images and words in the poem or song stir up your emotions, ideas or memories. 
  • To interpret mean to find meaning in the poem or song.
  • to evaluate  means to rate the value of the poem or song in some way.

Optional

Check out the worksheet and test yourself. (Feel free to contact me if you need help)

Need more examples? 

If viewing a completed essay helps you organize your essay for content and format, see the following essay:

Central Idea and Thesis

Your essay must have a clearly linked central idea, its thesis and their topic sentences.

  • Topic Sentences
  • Each paragraph should have its own topic sentence that combines the central idea and one reason or topic stated in your thesis in some way. 
  • Make the first or second sentence of each body paragraph your topic sentence and underline it. Each topic sentence should be one sentence long.

What Should You know Before You Start? 

  • The difference between experiencing, interpreting and evaluating a poem or song.
  • How to write about your experience, interpretation and evaluation of a poem or song.
  • How to formulate a central idea, its thesis and their topic sentences.
  • What elements/devices are within the work and how they determine or enhance the meaning you’ve given the poem or song.
  • I’ll look for how your central idea, its thesis and their topic sentences are linked together.
  •  I’ll look at how clearly you develop your ideas.
  • I’ll look at each body paragraph for its unity (about one thing) and coherence (sentences logically follow one another). 
  • I’ll be check your MLA formatting, your grammar, your punctuation and your mechanics,

 

 

Select “Next” to progress through the module.  

View Rubric

Essay 1 (1)
Essay 1 (1)
Criteria Ratings Pts
INTRODUCTION, STRUCTURE OF BODY (TOPIC SENTENCES) AND CONCLUSION
view longer description
/ 20 pts
BODY OF ESSAY
view longer description
/ 35 pts
Additional Materials Placed at end of essay.
view longer description
/ 20 pts
Grammar and Format
view longer description
/ 10 pts
How well you address the prompt as a Reader-Response
/ 15 pts
Total Points: 0

Casebooks

Civil Rights/Protest Poems/Songs

Poems

  • .Langston Hughes
    • ”Harlem”
    • ”I, Too”
  • Dudley Randall
    • ”Birmingham’
  • Maya Angelou
    • ”Caged Bird”
  • Yesika Salgado
    • “Brown Girl”
  • Gil Scott Heron
    • “The Revolution Will Not Be Televised”

Songs

  • Sung by Billie Holiday, written by Abel Merapol
    • ”Strange Fruit
  • Michael Jackson 
    • ”Black and White”
  • Bob Dylan
    •  “Times They are a’changin”
    • Masters of War”

Parent-Child Poems/Songs

Poems

Father-Son Relationship

  • Robert Hayden

    • “Those Winter Sundays”

  • Theodore Roethke

    • ‘My Papa’s Waltz”

Mother-Daughter Relationship

  • Janice Mirakitani 
    • “Breaking Tradition, for my Daughter”
  • Sharon Olds
    • “35/10” 

Parent-Child

  • Yesika Salgado
    • “My Name”

Songs

  • Bob Dylan
    • ”Hard Rains Gonna Fall” 
    • “Forever Young sung by Joan Baez
  • Lee Ann Womack
    • ”I Hope You Dance”

Love Poems/Songs

Poems

  • Pablo Neruda 
    •  “Tonight I Can Write the saddest lines”

  • Emily Dickinson
    • “Wild nights – Wild nights!” (269)
  • Adrienne Rich
    • “II” & “XV11” from Twenty One Love Poems
  • Yesika Salgado
    • “The Return”

Songs

  • “Love is Just a Four-Letter Word” by Joan Baez
  • “Love Minus Zero” by Bob Dylan
  • “Dance Me to the End of Love” By Leonard Cohen
  • “Crying in the Club” or “Easy” by Camila Cabello 
  • “Find Your Love” by Drake
  • “Someone You Loved” by Lewis Capaldi
  • “You are Love” or “This Love” by Taylor Swift

Individual Artists’ Poems or Songs

 Bob Dylan

  • “Love is Just a Four-Letter Word” sung by Joan Baez
  • “Love Minus Zero” 
  •  “Times They Are A-changin”
  • ”Hard Rains Gonna Fall” 
  • “Forever Young sung by Joan Baez
  • “Masters of War”

Yesika Salgado

  • “The Return.”
  • “My Name”
  • “Fat Girl Wants Love”
  • “Brown Girl”
  • “Unknown”
  • “Asking.”

    I have chosen Camilla Cabello – no crying in the club, but per instruction need one more comparable from this list. I have no preference as to which song you use for this. let me know if you would like me to chose.

    I MUST get an A (over 90%) for this paper and this class to get the GPA I nneed.

Are you struggling with your paper? Let us handle it - WE ARE EXPERTS!

Whatever paper you need - we will help you write it

Get started

Starts at $9 /page

How our paper writing service works

It's very simple!

  • Fill out the order form

    Complete the order form by providing as much information as possible, and then click the submit button.

  • Choose writer

    Select your preferred writer for the project, or let us assign the best writer for you.

  • Add funds

    Allocate funds to your wallet. You can release these funds to the writer incrementally, after each section is completed and meets your expected quality.

  • Ready

    Download the finished work. Review the paper and request free edits if needed. Optionally, rate the writer and leave a review.