This assignment provides you with another opportunity to practice critical reading, summarization and paraphrasing skills and making a historical argument based on primary source evidence.Write a 2000-word analytical essay that is thesis-driven and evidence-based.
Write an essay that explains and analyzes the perspectives of each writer on the issue. You can organize the paper in the way that seems best to you, but in general, the essay should contain the following components:
-
-
- An introduction
-
-
-
-
- Shape your introduction like a funnel while introducing the topic and each perspective.
- Write a thesis statement. Your thesis statement should indicate which perspective is the most persuasive. Nuanced arguments that effectively appreciate and critique both perspectives will be much stronger than those that simply choose a side.
- Some historical background.
- Be sure to summarize the historical background thoroughly yet concisely for this issue. Should be 1 paragraph max.
- A summary of the arguments
- What problem does each author address, what is the significance of that problem, and how does each author address it with an argument?
- Analysis of the sources
- What do these sources tell us about the issue, and in what ways do they speak to each other?
- In what context were these sources written? How might the context have influenced the authors’ perspectives?
- What are the areas of commonality? Think of approach, evidence, claims, problems, thesis, and conclusions.
- What are the major differences between the sources? Think of approach, evidence, claims, problems, thesis, and conclusions.
- Conclusion
- Summarize your thesis and main points
- Try to expand and connect this debate to the present. Think: what can this debate tell us about similar issues we face today?
-
-
Criteria
Submit your paper to this assignment box.
Writing Standards:
These papers will be evaluated based on the attached rubric. Please refer to this rubric for precise assessment scoring guidelines.
Remember to Cite all of your sources in Chicago Style and include a Bibliography at the end of your paper.
For additional tips on how to write Essays please refer to the Course Reader (p. 28). Under “Student Resources”, in the Modules folder, you will find a document titled Writing an Essay that contains helpful tips for every step of the writing process. I