The Role and Effectiveness of Experimental Therapy in Managing PTSD Symptoms Among Motor Vehicle Accident Survivors

Instructions for Draft 1 – Public Health Significance


OVERVIEW


In the public health significance (PHS) section, you are writing the first draft of your APA-style research proposal. Please use the Microsoft Word template we have created to guide you in formatting. Please also refer to the APA Publication Manual, 7th Edition or the APA Style Blog.  


Requirements for Draft 1:

  • A minimum of 3 empirical articles

  • Cite the DSM-5 for your operational definition

  • APA Style formatting

  • Clear writing

  • A title page (page 1) 

  • An aim statement (page 2) 

  • The PHS section (starts on page 3)

  • In-text citations (throughout the PHS section)

  • References (starts on a new page after the last page of your PHS). 

  • Submit your draft on the Canvas submission portal as a Word document (.doc or .docx), OneDrive link, or Google Docs link. We will provide you with detailed comments, which cannot be added to a PDF file.

  • Submit PDFs of all of the articles you reference in your paper on Canvas via the submission portal. 


See below for more detail.


★ SOURCES

Using Google Scholar or EBSCO (through SJU Libraries), find at least three articles that relate to the public health significance of your behavioral health disorder and the risk factor. There are several resources on Canvas, and finding sources will also be discussed in the lab and lecture. The DSM-5 must also be cited for your operational definition of the disorder.

★ CREATE A TITLE PAGE FOR YOUR TERM PAPER

Proposal Title 

The title of the paper must include the name of the behavioral health disorder, the risk factor, the mechanism, and the name of the experimental treatment. Use this template as a model: 



Effectiveness of the Experimental Treatment in Addressing Symptoms of [PTSD] and Mechanism in Individuals with the Disorder Who [Gender and ethnicity played significant roles, with women and people  of color (POC) more at risk.] 


Important Note: The title we are asking you to create for this course is longer than what is permitted for APA style journals. However, the longer titles we are using in the class will help you keep your thoughts organized and recognize where you are in the development of your proposal. For this reason, we are permitting titles longer than the standard 12 words. 


Note that you haven’t identified a mechanism or experimental treatment yet, so just leave those as “Experimental Treatment” and “Mechanism” in your title for Draft 1 (they are placeholders). You will fill these in during later drafts.


Example PHS titles: 


  • Effectiveness of the Experimental Treatment in Addressing Symptoms of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Mechanism in Motor Vehicle Accident Survivors

  • Effectiveness of the Experimental Treatment in Addressing Symptoms of Borderline Personality Disorder and Mechanism in Individuals with a History of Sexual Abuse

Title Case

Your title must be in title case. This means:


  • In title case, capitalize the following words in a title or heading: 

    • the first word, even a minor word such as “The” 

    • the first word of a subtitle, even if it is a minor word 

    • the first word after a colon (:), em dash (—), or end punctuation in a heading (. or ?), even if it is a minor word major words, including the second part of hyphenated major words (e.g., “Self-Report,” not “Self-report”) 

    • words of four letters or more (e.g., “With,” “Between,” “From”) 

  • Lowercase should only be used for minor words that are three letters or fewer in a title or heading (except the first word in a title or subtitle or the first word after a colon, em dash, or end punctuation in a heading): 

    • short conjunctions (e.g., “and,” “as,” “but,” “for,” “if,” “nor,” “or,” “so,” “yet”) 

    • articles (“a,” “an,” “the”) 

    • short prepositions (e.g., “as,” “at,” “by,” “for,” “in,” “of,” “off,” “on,” “per,” “to,” “up,” “via”)


★ DEVELOP A TEMPORARY DRAFT OF THE AIM STATEMENT

 

The aim statement should be the second page of this draft, after the title page. Create an initial aim statement for your term paper that includes only the risk factor and the disorder. The rest of the statement will be left blank for this draft. 


Your aim statement should be in this format: 



The aim of the present study is to test the hypothesis that the experimental treatment is better than the control treatment at improving the mechanism and decreasing symptoms of [insert behavioral health disorder] in individuals with [insert risk factor].


Example PHS aim statements:

 

  • The aim of the present study is to test the hypothesis that the experimental treatment is better than the control treatment at improving the mechanism and decreasing symptoms of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) in individuals with a parental history of OCD.

  • The aim of the present study is to test the hypothesis that the experimental treatment is better than the control treatment at improving the mechanism and decreasing symptoms of major depressive disorder (MDD) in adults with a family history of depression. 


★ CREATE THE PUBLIC HEALTH SIGNIFICANCE SECTION OF YOUR PAPER


Your PHS section will begin on page 3 of your paper. This section includes 6 components, which should be included in your paper in the following order:

Component 1: An operational definition of the behavioral health disorder you have chosen

For your operational definition of the disorder you must reference the DSM-5. Of course, you are welcome to cite other sources, but the DSM-5 should be your primary source in your first paragraph of the paper. This definition should be paraphrased from the DSM-5.

Component 2: The prevalence/incidence of the behavioral health disorder in the general population (US or global)

Provide statistics on the incidence or prevalence of the disorder in the general population (the US or globally). This will allow you to answer the question, “How many people have symptoms of this disorder?”


When reporting on prevalence or incidence, you should cite empirical journal articles. An empirical research article reports the results of a study that uses data derived from actual observation or experimentation (a meta-analysis or systematic review would be fine as well). Empirical research articles are examples of primary research.

Component 3: Consequences of the behavioral health disorder

Provide information on the consequences of the behavioral health disorder you’ve selected. Consequences are outcomes associated with the disorder, if the disorder is left untreated. Consequences of the disorder can include physical health impairments, other (comorbid) mental health conditions, impairments in occupational or educational functioning, impairments in social or role functioning, impairments in quality of life, among other difficulties. (Note: Consequences are not symptoms of the disorder.)

Component 4: Risk factors for the behavioral health disorder

Identify multiple risk factors for the disorder and select one risk to focus on in your paper. Potential risk factors could include gender, history of stress or trauma, family history of the illness, among other risk factors. Make sure to operationally define the risk factor you have chosen. 


When introducing the operational definition for the risk factor, you are permitted to use .gov sites or review articles, in addition to review articles.  A review article is an article that summarizes the current state of understanding on a topic; it surveys and summarizes previously published studies, rather than reporting new facts or analysis. You must also include studies that demonstrate a connection between the risk factor and the disorder; you can use original research articles or review articles.

Component 5: Prevalence/incidence of the risk factor/risk group in the general population

Provide statistical information on the prevalence/incidence of the risk factor in the general population.


When reporting on prevalence or incidence, you should cite empirical journal articles. An empirical research article reports the results of a study that uses data derived from actual observation or experimentation. Empirical research articles are examples of original research conducted by the authors and are a primary source for information.

Component 6: Prevalence/incidence of the behavioral health disorder within the risk group

Provide information on the prevalence/incidence of the disorder in individuals who have the risk factor.


When reporting on prevalence or incidence, you should cite empirical journal articles. An empirical research article reports the results of a study that uses data derived from actual observation or experimentation. Empirical research articles are original research conducted by the authors.

★ APA STYLE IN-TEXT CITATIONS

Your PHS section must feature in-text citations in APA style (7th Edition), so that you credit the original source of the information. You are expected to paraphrase, as opposed to quoting from the original text. You should cite in the paper each time you use factual information; you are not expected to cite when you include your opinion. Examples of how to cite in text from Purdue OWL:

Example narrative citations: 

  • Mougni et al. (2020) found that… 

  • In their study, Richard and Simmons (1970) identified that…

  • According to Jones (1998), American Psychiatric  Association (APA) style is a difficult citation format for first-time learners.

  • The American Psychiatric  Association’s (APA; 2013) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed.; DSM-5) characterizes X disorder as…

  • Subsequent narrative citations would be: Per APA (2013)…

Example parenthetical citations:

  • Wooly mammoths are indeed extinct (Kawashima et al., 2010). 

  • The participants completed self-reported surveys assessing for anxiety symptoms (Gupta & Suarez, 2015).

  • American Psychiatric  Association (APA) style is a difficult citation format for first-time learners (Jones, 1998).

  • According to the Diagnostic and Statistical  Manual  of  Mental  Disorders  (5th ed.; DSM-5; American Psychiatric Association [APA], 2013), X disorder is…

  • Subsequent parenthetical citations: (APA, 2013)

★ APA STYLE REFERENCES SECTION FOR YOUR PAPER

Create a references list for the end of the paper. This must be in APA style.

The references must be produced by Mendeley. Please list your reference manager in parentheses at the top of the References section.

 

Note that selecting appropriate sources to support your claims will be a factor in the grading process. For example, the appropriate source for an operational definition of the disorder is the DSM-5. The appropriate sources for the prevalence of the disorder would be an original empirical research article describing a study in which the researchers collected data on the prevalence of the disorder.

Article (simple) breakdown:

  1. PTSD prevalence (https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s13033-018-0229-8)

1. Background: Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a common mental health condition among survivors of road traffic accidents (RTAs), but little research has been conducted in low and middle-income countries like Ethiopia. The study aimed to assess the prevalence and factors associated with PTSD in this context.


2. Methods: A cross-sectional study was conducted in May 2016 at public hospitals in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. The PTSD Checklist-Specific version (PCL-S) questionnaire was used to assess participants. A total of 492 RTA survivors were included in the study, selected through systematic sampling.


3. Results: 

   – The prevalence of PTSD was found to be 22.8% among survivors of road traffic accidents.

   – Key factors significantly associated with PTSD were:

     – Being female (females were more than twice as likely as males to develop PTSD).

     – Poor social support.

     – Having depression.

     – Duration since the accident (those assessed 1–3 months after the accident were more likely to develop PTSD than those assessed after more than 3 months).


4. Conclusion: PTSD was found to be prevalent among RTA survivors in Ethiopia, especially in women, those with poor social support, and those with co-occurring depression. This suggests a need for early screening and intervention for PTSD among RTA survivors.


The study emphasizes the importance of integrating mental health services into primary care for early diagnosis and treatment of PTSD in low-resource settings.


  1. DSM-5 PTSD prev (https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0059236&type=printable)

1. Objective: The study conducted a systematic review of the literature to examine the longitudinal course of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in DSM-5 defined trauma-exposed populations, with a focus on distinguishing between intentional and non-intentional traumatic events.


2. Methods: The review analyzed 58 articles, representing 35 unique populations, which examined PTSD prevalence at two or more time points within 12 months of a traumatic event. The traumatic events were categorized as either intentional (e.g., assault, war) or unintentional (e.g., natural disasters, accidents).



3. Key Findings:

   – **PTSD Prevalence**: The overall prevalence of PTSD decreased over time, from an average of 28.8% at 1 month to 17.0% at 12 months. However, the course of PTSD varied depending on the type of trauma.

   – Intentional vs. Non-Intentional Trauma: PTSD prevalence decreased over time for non-intentional traumatic events (e.g., motor vehicle accidents), while it increased for intentional trauma (e.g., assaults or combat). The median PTSD prevalence for non-intentional trauma dropped from 30.1% at 1 month to 14.0% at 12 months, while for intentional trauma, it increased from 11.8% to 23.3%.

   – **PTSD Trajectories**: Of those exposed to intentional trauma, about 37.1% developed PTSD within the first year. Among those diagnosed with PTSD, approximately 34.8% remitted after 3 months, while 39.1% followed a chronic course. Only 3.5% of new PTSD cases appeared after the initial 3 months.


4. Implications: The study emphasizes that the type of trauma (intentional vs. non-intentional) significantly influences the prevalence and trajectory of PTSD. This knowledge is critical for public health planning and treatment interventions, as intentional traumas tend to result in a more prolonged and chronic course of PTSD.


5. Conclusions: The findings underscore the importance of understanding the different courses of PTSD based on the type of trauma, which can help inform resource allocation and treatment strategies. Additionally, more longitudinal studies are needed to better understand PTSD trajectories over time, particularly for non-intentional trauma events


  1. Prevalence, Demographic, and Clinical Correlates of Likely PTSD (https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/18/12/6227)

Objective: The study aimed to evaluate the prevalence and factors associated with likely post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in subscribers of the Text4Hope service during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Methodology: The study involved a cross-sectional survey administered to subscribers of Text4Hope, a free mental health support service, over a three-month period during the pandemic. The PTSD Checklist for DSM-5 (PCL-5) was used to assess symptoms. Demographic and clinical data were also collected.

Prevalence of PTSD:

  • The study found a high prevalence of likely PTSD (46.8%) among the survey respondents, with the highest prevalence reported among individuals identifying as “other gender” (66.7%).

Risk Factors for PTSD:

  • Several factors were associated with an increased likelihood of PTSD:

    • Fear of contracting COVID-19.

    • History of depression before the pandemic.

    • Receiving counseling during the pandemic.

    • Living in rented accommodations.

    • Identifying as Indigenous.

Protective Factors:

  • Subscribers who received absolute support from family and friends had lower odds of developing PTSD. Social support was identified as a key protective factor in reducing PTSD symptoms.

Sociodemographic Correlates:

  • Subscribers who were unemployed, self-isolated or quarantined, or lacked sufficient support from employers also exhibited higher likelihoods of PTSD.

Clinical Correlates:

  • History of mental health diagnoses, such as anxiety or depression, and prior use of psychotropic medications were significant predictors of likely PTSD.

Conclusions:

  • The study highlights the mental health impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and the importance of targeted mental health interventions, particularly for vulnerable groups like Indigenous people, those with pre-existing mental health conditions, and those with limited social support. It suggests public health campaigns should include mental health support strategies during pandemics.

  1.  Predictors of the development and maintenance of posttraumatic stress disorder following a motor vehicle accident: a path analytic approach

1. Definition and Overview of PTSD: Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is described as a mental health condition triggered by a terrifying event, either experiencing it or witnessing it. PTSD is characterized by intrusive thoughts, avoidance of trauma-related stimuli, alterations in cognition and mood, and hyperarousal.

2. Prevalence Rates: The prevalence of PTSD varies significantly depending on the nature of the traumatic event. Studies suggest that the overall prevalence decreases from 28.8% at one month post-trauma to 17.0% at 12 months. However, intentional trauma (e.g., violence) tends to result in a higher prevalence of PTSD compared to non-intentional trauma (e.g., accidents).

3. Course and Trajectory of PTSD: PTSD can follow different trajectories. Approximately 34.8% of those diagnosed remit within three months, while about 39.1% have a chronic course. New cases of PTSD post-trauma are rare after the first three months, accounting for only 3.5% of cases.

4.Comorbidities: PTSD often coexists with other mental health conditions, such as depression and substance use disorders, particularly alcohol abuse. Comorbid conditions are common and contribute to the complexity of treatment and recovery.

5. Factors Influencing PTSD Severity: The severity of PTSD symptoms is influenced by pre-trauma factors (e.g., previous mental health issues), the nature of the trauma, and post-trauma factors (e.g., social support, coping mechanisms). Additionally, physical disability and emotional distress following trauma are significant predictors of long-term PTSD outcomes.

6. Clinical Implications: The findings underscore the importance of early interventions, particularly for individuals exposed to intentional trauma. Understanding the specific risk factors and trajectories of PTSD can aid in developing targeted public health interventions to support those affected by trauma.

F) Risk factor/gender race (https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Brittany-Hall-Clark/publication/306381344_RacialEthnic_Differences_in_Symptoms_of_Posttraumatic_Stress_Disorder/links/5ec54a33a6fdcc90d6872ff5/Racial-Ethnic-Differences-in-Symptoms-of-Posttraumatic-Stress-Disorder.pdf

Objective: The article reviews racial and ethnic differences in the prevalence and symptom expression of PTSD among major racial/ethnic groups in the U.S. (African Americans, Hispanics/Latinos, and Asians/Asian Americans). The review also considers cultural factors such as trauma exposure, acculturation, and experiences of racism.

PTSD Prevalence:

  • African Americans have a higher prevalence of PTSD compared to non-Latino Whites.

  • Latinos, especially those exposed to trauma, also show higher conditional risk for PTSD.

  • Asian Americans report lower levels of PTSD prevalence but face unique cultural factors in symptom expression.

Cultural and Sociopolitical Factors:

  • Cultural and racial experiences, including discrimination and socioeconomic status, significantly influence PTSD symptomatology. African Americans and Latinos face higher trauma exposure due to socioeconomic conditions, while Asians report different trauma types, such as political violence.

Racial Differences in Trauma Exposure:

  • African Americans are more likely to experience interpersonal violence and community violence.

  • Latinos face significant trauma from violence and natural disasters.

  • Asians, although reporting lower trauma exposure, encounter political violence in their countries of origin.

Cultural Variations in Symptom Expression:

  • PTSD symptoms manifest differently across ethnic groups, with African Americans more prone to dissociation and psychotic symptoms, Latinos to avoidance and dissociation, and Asian Americans often somatizing symptoms.

  • Cultural expressions of PTSD, such as ataque de nervios in Latinos, also affect diagnosis and treatment.

Social and Mental Health Impact:

  • Racial/ethnic minorities experience unique stressors like racism and acculturation stress, which may exacerbate PTSD symptoms.

  • Discrimination can lead to PTSD symptoms, with hypervigilance and negative cognitions prevalent in African Americans, while Latinos may experience delayed onset PTSD.

Implications for Treatment:

  • The review highlights the need for culturally sensitive assessment and treatment approaches, including addressing language barriers and considering the impact of racism in diagnosis.

  • There is a need for more research into the effects of cultural factors, such as acculturation, on PTSD symptoms and treatment outcomes.

H) Gender/race risk factor cont…. (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6870874/pdf/nihms-1542588.pdf

Objective and Methodology:

  • The study aimed to evaluate the risk of exposure to potentially traumatic events (PTEs) and the diagnosis of PTSD among different genders, stratified by race/ethnicity.

  • Data from three national studies (Collaborative Psychiatric Epidemiology Surveys, CPES) involving 13,649 participants were used, employing regression analyses to examine the relationship between PTEs, PTSD, and gender across racial/ethnic groups.

Findings:

  • Adjusting for sociodemographic variables and other factors, women of White, African-American, and Afro-Caribbean descent had higher odds of PTSD compared to men in their respective groups. Gender differences were not noted among Latinos or Asians.

  • Factors like mental health comorbidity, social support, and type and frequency of PTE exposure varied significantly by gender and race/ethnicity.

  • Women were more likely to report exposure to sexual-type PTEs, while men reported more exposure to accidents, combat, and physical assaults.

  • Social and cultural factors play a critical role in the risk and diagnosis of PTSD, suggesting that these elements should be considered in future PTSD assessments and treatments.

Conclusions:

  • The risk of PTE exposure and PTSD diagnosis differs significantly by gender and racial/ethnic background.

  • The study underscores the importance of considering social, cultural, and contextual factors when assessing PTSD risks across different demographics.


*PLEASE THOROUGHLY AND PROPERLY FOLLOW THE RUBRIC AND TEMPLATE*

Are you struggling with your paper? Let us handle it - WE ARE EXPERTS!

Whatever paper you need - we will help you write it

Get started

Starts at $9 /page

How our paper writing service works

It's very simple!

  • Fill out the order form

    Complete the order form by providing as much information as possible, and then click the submit button.

  • Choose writer

    Select your preferred writer for the project, or let us assign the best writer for you.

  • Add funds

    Allocate funds to your wallet. You can release these funds to the writer incrementally, after each section is completed and meets your expected quality.

  • Ready

    Download the finished work. Review the paper and request free edits if needed. Optionally, rate the writer and leave a review.